(Nov. 5) -- An elite group of scientists who advise the government on national security issues has issued a harsh critique of attempts to predict 9/11-type attacks. There is "no credible approach that has been documented to date" for predicting terrorist or weapons of mass destruction attacks," the group concluded in a study obtained by the Federation of American Scientists.
That statement may seem glaringly obvious to some, but it counters the Pentagon's predeliction for funding social scientists to come up with models that predict the future. The critical study was performed by JASON, a little-known group of academics who counsel the Pentagon and other agencies on science issues.
The report does not mention by name any of a number of ongoing Defense Department projects to build predictive models of various sorts. The Pentagon's Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, for example, funds a program called the Integrated Crisis Warning System that "seeks to develop a comprehensive, integrated, automated, generalizable, and validated system to monitor, assess, and forecast national, sub-national, and international crises..." Another Pentagon office funds a program called "Human, Social, Cultural, & Behavioral Modeling," which also looks at ways to forecast behavior.
A paramedic treats mock victims during an emergency preparedness drill in New York.
In other words, predicting events after they happen is easy; it's predicting them ahead of time that's hard.
The JASON report underscores the difference between predicting events -- which it considers impossible -- and assessing risk. The group wrote that "another 9/11-scale event in the world is unlikely but not improbable in the next ten years." But what are the chances of another such event happening, according to the group?
They took a stab at that one at least: 7 percent.

Genetic tests for UK asylum seekers draw criticism LONDON (AP) Britain is using genetic tests on some African asylum seekers in an effort to catch those who are lying about their nationality,...
More than 400 Product Ratings for LCD & Plasma TVs, Blu-Ray Players, Computers, Digital & SLR Cameras, Headphones and More YONKERS, N.Y., Nov. 2 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The annual Consumer Reports...
Get a better brew with models ranging from $20 to $100 YONKERS, N.Y., Nov. 2 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- As more and more consumers look for ways to save money, many may be trading their beloved...